The military figures prominently in Israeli society, some say too prominently and well, there is certainly a debate to be had on that subject. However that conversation, we will save for another time.
It is important to remember that the IDF is an instrument of the democratically elected government of Israel. The IDF does not and should not have a say in policy. It is there to carry out the policies and orders of the government of the day.
In a highly politicised society where people are active and passionate on all sides of the political debate, maintaining the apolitical nature of the IDF is paramount. When the uniform goes on then political views need to be left at the door or gate if you prefer.
The disgraceful display of political protest during the Kfir unit's ceremony at the wailing wall, marking the end of basic training for new recruits; represents a clear and present danger to the security of the state. The overtly political display threatens the very nature of the IDF and its effectiveness as a military unit. When individual or groups of soldiers start choosing what missions they will or will not perform, then the security of the state is under threat. The actions of these young soldiers and their families, who joined their protest from the spectators gallery; only serve to undermine the defense of the country.
The soldiers must be disciplined to the full capacity of the military courts. In addition there should be an investigation to see if the family members who waved banners at the ceremony are guilty of inciting soldiers to refuse orders, and if they are, they should be prosecuted.
I must stress this is not about left and right. This is not about West Bank or Judea and Samaria. This is not about... should settlements be evacuated or not. This is about the very survival of the state of Israel as a democratic state and the IDF's ability to defend it. If you think I am being over dramatic then think again.
As soldier fighting in Beirut during the first Lebanon war in 1982, I remember the huge demonstration in Rabin Square (Malchey Yisrael at the time). While we were up there fighting, we heard around four hundred thousand people demonstrated against the war. We were angry and felt betrayed, well some of us did and then again some did not, in fact several of the guys who were out on leave attended that demonstration before returning for duty not long after. Like it or not, the demonstration was a legitimate display of political opinion in a democratic country, legitimate in civilian life... however not in uniform. And it is imperative that in a country which depends upon citizens from all backgrounds and sides of the political spectrum to serve and defend the nation, that this distinction be maintained.
I am firmly of the opinion that you cannot choose if or where you serve or what tasks you will or will not perform. You can only choose how you will serve and in what manner you will carry out your orders. You can of course refuse to carry out an illegal order. However, what and what is not illegal, again is for the courts to decide, not individuals.
Just as soldiers with left wing opinions should not have been allowed to refuse to serve in Lebanon or today on the West Bank, so too soldiers with right wing opinions should not be allowed to refuse to evacuate settlements or to perform any other task demanded of them by their officers and ultimately their government. You cannot call one side traitors for their actions and then betray your country in the very same manner. Many left wing refusniks have served jail time for their refusal. It is important that right wing refusniks be treated in the same manner.
In recent times there has been far too many attempts to promote political and religious agendas within the IDF. Those responsible must be brought to account and the IDF must defend itself from all such attempts regardless of which side of the argument they may come from.
No comments:
Post a Comment